CMP EMBEDDED.COM

Login | Register     Welcome Guest  
HOME DESIGN PRODUCTS COLUMNS E-LEARNING CONFERENCES CODE FORUMS/BLOGS NEWSLETTERS CONTACT FEATURES RSS RSS

Eeny, Meeny, Miney, Moe: choosing a low power wireless network protocol - Part 2
Additional criteria to consider



Embedded.com

802.15.4
The 802.15.4 standard is a low power, wireless networking standard developed by the IEEE 802.15 Task Group 4. The standard was released in 2003 and has since been revised and superseded by the 2006 version, but originated as a response to the growing number of electronic designers that voiced the need for a standard addressing low-complexity, low data rate, and (most commonly) battery-operated implementations.

Specifically, development of the standard targeted applications in the home automation, industrial controls, agriculture, and security market sectors. There are several other protocols including ZigBee and ZigBee Pro that incorporate 802.15.4 as the physical and data link layer.

One may hear the 802.15.4 standard referred to as the MAC, or Medium Access Control standard, as it defines the communication protocol between any two peer devices in a network. A device on an 802.15.4 personal area network (PAN) can be implemented conceptually as either a Full Function Device (FFD) or a Reduced Function Device (RFD).

An FFD node maintains the capabilities of a network coordinator and is more likely to be mains powered, although the device may not always be used as such due to the fact that each PAN in a star configuration can only have a single coordinator node.

An FFD could function as a common node. An RFD node is designedly less complex, meaning it cannot assume the responsibilities of a network coordinator and can only speak to an FFD node.

An RFD node will carry a minimal implementation of the application, hence reducing the cost of the IC, is likely to be the node enabling the sensor or the actuator for the application, and is also more likely to be battery-powered, requiring extremely low duty cycles of operation.

As Figure 7 below shows, the star topology of an 802.15.4 network can be extended when an FFD coordinator assigns a new PAN identifier (PAN ID) to one of its children nodes (that must also be an FFD), creating a cluster of PANs where only the coordinator nodes can exchange information. Note that routing is not directly supported by the standard.

Figure 7 -- network configurations for 802.15.4

By defining the communication between two nodes, including a basis for network management, the 802.15.4 standard presents a flexible foundation for the development of higher-level network implementations such as ZigBee.

Although it is a good foundation for higher-level network development, the 802.15.4 standard maintains a certain level of complexity that allows it to be employed "as-is" as a reliable method of communication given the right application considerations. Generally, a designer should consider the 802.15.4 standard as a fit for his or her application if it requires the following:

Faith in an industry-standardized physical layer and lower layer protocol
Freedom to design own higher layer protocol
Free choice of different HW and lower-layer SW vendors
Interoperability on the physical and lower protocol layer
Lower cost on design and development
Support and maintenance by other vendors/providers

and can accept drawbacks such as:

The design and development of higher layer protocol and application Radio channel restrictions according to the standard.

1 | 2 | 3

Rate this article: Low High
Current rating
  • .
Embedded.com Career Center
Looking for a new job?
SEARCH JOBS

Browse all jobs

SPONSOR
RECENT JOB POSTINGS





 :